General Impression: Awesome! Best ever! (Top 5%) Good guy! (Top 20%) I would be ok hiring him! (Top 40%) I see too many red flags! (Not top 40%)
How do you rate the applicant's technical knowledge?: Awesome! Best ever! (Top 5%) Good guy! (Top 20%) I would be ok hiring him! (Top 40%) I see too many red flags! (Not top 40%)
How informed was the guy about our group? Awesome! Best ever! (Top 5%) Good guy! (Top 20%) Sufficiently knowledgeable! (Top 40%) Had no clue about us! (Not top 40%)
How do you rate the personal impression, soft skills, etc? Awesome! Best friends forever! Good guy! My future office mate! I would be ok as long as he is not my desk neighbor! I can't stand him! Many red flags!
Please make sure to assign "peters" as the next reviewer if you feel that there are too many red flags.
Topics covered: Whatever topics...
Feel free to pick up topics again even if previously covered by other group members. However, we should do every topic at least once. Note that the topic refers to your assessment of the issue but not the actual question.
Topic 1: Quality of Machine Learning Knowledge Quality of Robotics Knowledge Quality of Control Knowledge Experience with Machine Learning on Interesting Data Experience with Real Robots Experience with Real Systems Control Programming abilities (e.g., C, MATLAB, Python) Computing knowledge (e.g., Unix, networks, low-level programming) Systems knowledge (e.g., Sensors, Kinect, embedded systems) Suitable of the project (if applicable) Did the applicant study our website? Did the applicant read our related publications? Do you consider the applicant intelligent? Does the applicant have a good fundamental education? How are the applicant's soft skills? Does the applicant fit into the group (personality-wise)? What are the applicant's hobbies? Does the applicant appear highly motivated? How well can the applicant cope with pressure? Does the applicant prefer working/studying alone or in groups? How much supervision does the applicant require/expect? Which research topics does the applicant seem passionate about? Which aspects/areas of research does the applicant want to avoid? Is the applicant capable of being critical/reflexive about his/her own work?
Topic 2: Quality of Machine Learning Knowledge Quality of Robotics Knowledge Quality of Control Knowledge Experience with Machine Learning on Interesting Data Experience with Real Robots Experience with Real Systems Control Programming abilities (e.g., C, MATLAB, Python) Computing knowledge (e.g., Unix, networks, low-level programming) Systems knowledge (e.g., Sensors, Kinect, embedded systems) Suitable of the project (if applicable) Did the applicant study our website? Did the applicant read our related publications? Do you consider the applicant intelligent? Does the applicant have a good fundamental education? How are the applicant's soft skills? Does the applicant fit into the group (personality-wise)? What are the applicant's hobbies? Does the applicant appear highly motivated? How well can the applicant cope with pressure? Does the applicant prefer working/studying alone or in groups? How much supervision does the applicant require/expect? Which research topics does the applicant seem passionate about? Which aspects/areas of research does the applicant want to avoid? Is the applicant capable of being critical/reflexive about his/her own work?
Topic 3: Quality of Machine Learning Knowledge Quality of Robotics Knowledge Quality of Control Knowledge Experience with Machine Learning on Interesting Data Experience with Real Robots Experience with Real Systems Control Programming abilities (e.g., C, MATLAB, Python) Computing knowledge (e.g., Unix, networks, low-level programming) Systems knowledge (e.g., Sensors, Kinect, embedded systems) Suitable of the project (if applicable) Did the applicant study our website? Did the applicant read our related publications? Do you consider the applicant intelligent? Does the applicant have a good fundamental education? How are the applicant's soft skills? Does the applicant fit into the group (personality-wise)? What are the applicant's hobbies? Does the applicant appear highly motivated? How well can the applicant cope with pressure? Does the applicant prefer working/studying alone or in groups? How much supervision does the applicant require/expect? Which research topics does the applicant seem passionate about? Which aspects/areas of research does the applicant want to avoid? Is the applicant capable of being critical/reflexive about his/her own work?
Topic 4: Quality of Machine Learning Knowledge Quality of Robotics Knowledge Quality of Control Knowledge Experience with Machine Learning on Interesting Data Experience with Real Robots Experience with Real Systems Control Programming abilities (e.g., C, MATLAB, Python) Computing knowledge (e.g., Unix, networks, low-level programming) Systems knowledge (e.g., Sensors, Kinect, embedded systems) Suitable of the project (if applicable) Did the applicant study our website? Did the applicant read our related publications? Do you consider the applicant intelligent? Does the applicant have a good fundamental education? How are the applicant's soft skills? Does the applicant fit into the group (personality-wise)? What are the applicant's hobbies? Does the applicant appear highly motivated? How well can the applicant cope with pressure? Does the applicant prefer working/studying alone or in groups? How much supervision does the applicant require/expect? Which research topics does the applicant seem passionate about? Which aspects/areas of research does the applicant want to avoid? Is the applicant capable of being critical/reflexive about his/her own work?
Topic 5: Quality of Machine Learning Knowledge Quality of Robotics Knowledge Quality of Control Knowledge Experience with Machine Learning on Interesting Data Experience with Real Robots Experience with Real Systems Control Programming abilities (e.g., C, MATLAB, Python) Computing knowledge (e.g., Unix, networks, low-level programming) Systems knowledge (e.g., Sensors, Kinect, embedded systems) Suitable of the project (if applicable) Did the applicant study our website? Did the applicant read our related publications? Do you consider the applicant intelligent? Does the applicant have a good fundamental education? How are the applicant's soft skills? Does the applicant fit into the group (personality-wise)? What are the applicant's hobbies? Does the applicant appear highly motivated? How well can the applicant cope with pressure? Does the applicant prefer working/studying alone or in groups? How much supervision does the applicant require/expect? Which research topics does the applicant seem passionate about? Which aspects/areas of research does the applicant want to avoid? Is the applicant capable of being critical/reflexive about his/her own work?
Others: Anything else which you want to share with us?
Confidential Comments to Jan only: Feeling awkward to share this with the group?